Deli Market
in the Heart of Amish Country
Family Owned & Operated
Down the Aisle
Canned Goods
Canned Goods
Baked Goods
This is the heading
Bulk Foods
This is the heading
Local Produce
This is the heading
Housewares
Housewares
Home Decor
Home Decor
Gift Baskets
Gift Baskets & Boxes
Fresh In-House Creations
Fresh In-House Creations
Local Honey
Local Honey
Fresh Fruits
Fresh Fruits
Deli Platters
Deli Platters
Disposables
Disposables
Cheese
Our deli-sliced cheeses are crafted from the finest, freshest ingredients, offering you rich, creamy flavors and melt-in-your-mouth textures that take your sandwiches, wraps, and snacks to the next level. Whether you’re building a gourmet grilled cheese or adding a little something extra to your charcuterie board, our selection of deli cheeses will make every bite satisfying.
Meats
Are you craving the perfect sandwich or a quick snack? Our sliced deli meats are the ultimate in convenience and taste—perfectly sliced and ready to elevate any meal. Whether you’re making a classic turkey club, crafting a savory charcuterie board, or simply enjoying a snack, our deli meats are made from the finest cuts, carefully seasoned, and sliced fresh for great flavor.
Fresh Produce
Made In-House Fresh Pizzas, Casseroles, and More!
Our hand-crafted pizzas, casseroles, and snacks are made fresh in small batches, weekly in-house.
All of our casseroles are made in-house from scratch. They’re available fresh or frozen—just grab one and pop it in the oven to bake!
Treat your family to a meal that combines the convenience of fast food with the taste of home-cooked goodness. Simply grab a take-and-bake pizza, pop it in the oven, and enjoy!
Try Our Delicious
Deli Trays
Stress-Free Hosting
Ready-to-serve, beautifully presented
Fresh Ingredients
The products in our trays are carefully selected to include the freshest fruits, sliced meats, and cheeses.
Customizable Options
Tailor your tray to suit any taste or dietary need
Gift Baskets
Our deli gift baskets, filled with mouthwatering meats, gourmet cheeses, and artisanal snacks are great for any occasion, these baskets are a delicious way to show you care.
Order your deli gift basket today and make someone’s day extra special!
Grilled Sandwiches
Come in for our mouth-watering made-to-order grilled deli sandwiches. Perfect for lunch on the go!
Fresh Salads
Are you craving something light, healthy, and delicious? Our lunch salads are the perfect choice for a satisfying and nutritious meal.
Soups
There’s nothing like a steaming bowl of soup to warm the soul. Whether you’re looking for a hearty meal, a light snack, or something comforting on a chilly day, our soups make a great choice.
Ice Cream
Craving a sweet, creamy treat that hits the spot every time? Uncle Bob’s Homemade Ice cream is made from ingredients from local dairies and bakeries to ensure their icecream is fresh and homemade.
Google Reviews
Rose2024-10-27Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Our bi-yearly trip and, of course, our first stop in Arthur is Shady Credt Amish Grocery store, deli, ice cream shop, and gift store. No kidding, it started out as a little store & has grown dramatically over the years, which is great for the owners, tourists & community. Mind you, we stop for one major reason first. It's the fried pies people. If you've never had an Amish fried pie, you are truly missing out on the best little hand-held pie ever. They are kinda like the old old hostess pies only so much better. The flavors are so one of a kind. Let me see if I can do justice here. Lemon, cherry, apple, black Raspberry, peach, strawberry, pumpkin, and yes, I know I'm missing some ha. Anyways, if you don't get to Shady Crest first thing, guess what? They sell out, literally every time they are only available Friday & Saturday. Now there's your answer to why we go there first when we get to Arthur. Mind you, there is a method to my madness, lol. It's not the only thing we buy it depends on the pastries for the day and what products you might like to try. Like jams, rare cookies, pot pies, butter, so much to choose from that you don't find in any regular grocery store. Get a sandwich or ice cream or soda fountain drink. See what mean, it's a great locally-owned grocery store. For tourists, you'll definitely see horse & buggies in the parking lot, too. Be mindful, never ever take pictures of the Amish people in case you don't know. Adam Adams2024-10-07Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Best turkey & bacon sandwich I ever had Troy Rund2024-10-06Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Great place for lunch. Tanya Phillips2024-09-28Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I loved all the throwback candies. The granola is so moist. So good 👍 Nathan Beachy2024-08-19Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Delicious ice cream 🍦😋 Awesome sandwiches 🤠 Richard Thompsen2024-07-24Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Best place to shop for meat and cheese great baked goods there home made sandwiches are really good also just a great all around storeVerified by TrustindexTrustindex verified badge is the Universal Symbol of Trust. Only the greatest companies can get the verified badge who has a review score above 4.5, based on customer reviews over the past 12 months. Read more